specialk
This week we were going to review Garden of Life RAW Meal, but the product didn’t arrive on time. Instead of just sitting around twiddling our thumbs, someone mentioned that they had seen that Special K, had released a new weight loss shake. We ran to the store and stopped when we saw the product. Special K is marketing the product as a protein shake, not meal replacement. Given that we just spent the time to define the difference, we were going to pass the buck.

Until we looked at the label and saw that it only had 10 grams of protein per serving. Really? We bought strawberry and dark chocolate and here we are to give the rundown.

Value

9.0

We ended up spending 16$ for eight bottles so the shake is a getting a solid 9 with a $2 per shake price tag. There is a convenience factor here that means you can get the shake at the store. It’s immediately negated by the fact that it only comes in four serving canisters…so there’s the awkward event of filling your cart full of weight loss shakes each month. It’s a bit much for some of us.

Hunger Blocker

6.7

Given that they are calling this a protein shake, you shouldn’t expect this to contain a lot of hunger blocking. We certainly weren’t. The shake contains 5 grams of dietary fiber, but that’s pretty much the only hunger blocking it contains. How much does a glass of chocolate milk fill you up? Well, that’s about the same you should expect from the Special K shakes.

Nutrition

9.0

For a protein shake, 10 grams of protein is ridiculously low. For a meal replacement it’s about average. They also have about 35% of your daily vitamins and minerals per serving which is perfect for replacing one of your three meals. However, 29 grams of carbs, 18 grams of sugar and 190 calories are just too high for us to rate them higher.

Taste

8.6

These shakes had an interesting smell to them. Not bad, necessarily, just there. Some of us aren’t really fans of dark chocolate and this shake wasn’t going to convince us otherwise. The dark chocolate got a “meh, it’s not bad.” from the dark chocolate eaters and a “yeah, I didn’t think I would like it.” from the rest. The strawberry was pretty good but nothing special. It had the ‘I’m a protein shake’ vitamin taste to it.

So there you have it. If you were thinking of using these shakes as meal replacement, they can do a decent job at it. Not a terrific job, no, but decent. As a protein shake? We don’t run that site, but we don’t see it getting many high marks.

About Mrs. R

Mrs. R is the cumulative knowledge of the entire MRSR.com staff. She's got many, many years of fitness and health training under her belt.

If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it.
Pin It

Comments

  1. I’ve been replacing two meals a day with the Special K shakes in addition to exercise for 70 days . I have lost 30 pounds! These are great tasting and fill me up. (Which says a lot since I was a major over eater!) I frequently find myself craving a shake! I’ve tried the slim fast shakes, but they don’t keep me satisfied long. The Special K shakes are so good, even my finicky six year old daughter loves them. She drinks a shake as an after school snack every day! They care very convenient, tasty, and easy to buy at almost any store. I can buy 4 Special K shakes for about $6. That will last 2 days. I would recommend trying it If you’ve never tried meal replacement shakes before (like me.) This is a great way to try it out without spending much money up front or feeling overwhelmed.

    5
    • Hi Angie, I have never drank protein shakes before and was wondering if they are good and safe.I am starting to walk 5 days a week.I walk about 5-7 miles per day but need something eles to help with some weight lose.I feel great but not really seeing any progress.Help!!!!!. Joyce

      0
  2. I started drinking the special K shakes for breakfast when I have to be up early and moving. It’s hard for me to eat solid food first thing in the morning, but the shakes have allowed me to get my metabolism started right when I wake up. The milk chocolate is definitely the best tasting and I don’t even like chocolate milk that much. Strawberry and vanilla flavors definitely have the taste of protein shakes, but I don’t mind it and often blend fresh fruit into the vanilla ones.

    I’ve lost 15 pounds in the past 2.5 months and this is not because of the shakes, but they did help a lot. If you are looking to lose weight you have to control how much you consume. Replacing one meal a day is awesome, but if the rest of your meals are super high in calories, you will not lose weight!

    Back to the shakes, I love them! This morning I was out of them and stopped by fresh and easy, hoping to find at least one in the cooler because I found myself craving it! I wasn’t able to find it and settled for the closest thing I could find which was the light muscle milk. AWFUL. The taste of Special K is far superior and I love it!

    0
  3. I drink these dark chocolate shakes every day for breakfast because it’s easy, fast, and they taste absolutely GREAT! I crave them too. I haven’t lost any weight, but I only work out twice a week and don’t do much else in between. I am thinking of changing to 2 meals a day with the shakes. They do seem to ease the hunger, and I love the convenience. I’ve been doing this for about a year, and I’m not getting at all tired of the dark chocolate flavor at all.

    0
  4. Hi I am overweight. I work at a hospital and all the nurses are doing this expensive diet that I cannot afford. I was looking for a mealreplacement drink because I figured that was be a lot cheaper than trying to do it their way. So i googled what was a good meal replcement drink for women? and this drink came up. I want to use it because it sounds like it may work for me. Im currently 216lbs and Im 5’8 I want to get to 160lbs.So I have to lose 56lbs. I know its not going to happen overnight. But Im hoping this will help… any suggestions??

    0
    • Yes. Drink one to replace meals, try to find a shake that actually fills you up at a cost-effective price. Special K might work, it might not, but we do have a lot of other shakes that have 10′s in the Price category so you can try those too.

      Exercise regularly, and limit your other meals to keep yourself at about 1600-1800 calories per day. This will help with your initial weight loss.

      Keep your chin up and stay motivated. You can do it!

      0
  5. I have been on a steady pace with the meal replacement shake diet for about 9 weeks now. The problem I found for a lot of your suggestions, was the price. I was paying more for a “good” quality shake than I would for the ominous “brown sack lunch” from the “MC-Wendy-King-Bell-Way”, but my wife slipped in a 4-pack of the Special-K brand because she was tired of seeing the $50+ bill from GNC on the credit card, they were on sale, AND she had a coupon. I cracked one of them open, took a big gulp and nearly blew it back out on my computer screen… they were quite frankly, nasty. I could no longer choke them down after the third day of torture and thought I was going to be forced to pay the extortion prices of Shakeology or PGC for something tasty. However, something happened I did NOT expect. I found my co-worker drinking a MR shake on the next Monday afternoon. I was out of shakes myself, so I offered to buy one, thinking they would be $2-$3, I pulled out a $5. Wrong! she gave me one, and said she got them for $0.75/each. I thanked her, and asked her how many she had to buy to get that price. I also noted that I remember seeing the “Equate” brand but did not remember where. We exchanged weight loss counts for a brief moment, and that’s when she dropped the bomb, “It’s from Walmart.” I almost gave the shake back but I realized I had nothing to lose, plus I enjoy the masochistic tongue lashings on occasion so I puckered my lips, pinched my nose, and began to drink. To my amazement, I enjoyed the taste, and it kept me filled for the next few hours. I WAS AMAZED! A little short on the “fulfillment” category though. I have been drinking the Walmart brand shakes for 5 weeks now and I am still enjoying the flavor.
    Mrs. R mentioned there experience as, “meh, it’s not bad =’s an 8.6?!” I sincerely nominate her for the “Literary Understatement of the Year Award”. I’d give it a ~3. One mark for each day I was able to drink it. I cannot say enough discouraging things about the floury insta-choco flavoring these special-k brand shakes have. Go try the wally world shakes, I’m not kidding, and @ $0.75/each what have you got to lose.

    0
  6. I would like to tell you that i have started drinking the Special K protein shake
    and i thin it is wonderful, it is full of vitamins it is low fat and anything that will
    help curb my hunger cravings is great, your chocolate flavor is a bit BOLD and
    am wondering why such strong, overbearing taste of chocolate for such a nice
    meal replacement ???

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *